top of page

Payment options at checkout: why PayPal and Stripe matter

20somethingmedia
2 days ago
4 min read

Updated: 1 day ago

If you sell anything online, whether it is a side hustle, a small shop or freelance work taken through a payment link, the checkout page decides whether the sale happens. Most buyers will not argue with a checkout that is missing the one way they like to pay. They simply close the tab.


Why buyers leave when their preferred payment is missing


Baymard Institute puts the average cart abandonment rate at 70.22%. That average comes from 50 published studies between 2006 and 2025, so roughly seven in ten carts are left behind.


Not every abandoned cart is a payment problem. Baymard's latest US study of abandonment reasons, leaving out shoppers who were only browsing, found that 40% cited extra costs, 9% said there were not enough payment methods, and 10% said their card was declined. A missing option is not the biggest cause, but it is one you can fully control. Baymard's cart abandonment figures are published on its site.


Trust and security: protection without handing over your card details


A hand holds a phone at a worn wooden table, its screen blurred

Buyers want two things before they pay: a way to get their money back if the order goes wrong, and assurance that their card details are not spread around the internet. A familiar wallet such as PayPal covers both.


PayPal's Purchase Protection refunds eligible purchases when an item does not arrive or is significantly not as described, however the buyer pays. A dispute must be opened within 180 days of the payment. PayPal says claims are settled in 14 days on average, based on its own internal data from FYE 2022. Eligibility depends on the item and the transaction, and terms apply. PayPal's Purchase Protection page sets out what is covered.


Card details matter too. Stripe says its payment libraries collect card information without sensitive data ever reaching your own servers. That is a claim from the provider, so check its documentation before you rely on it. Stripe's pricing page describes its products.


Speed and conversion at the moment of payment


Every extra step at checkout is a chance to leave. Wallets and saved cards cut the typing. Stripe describes its Link accelerated checkout as three times faster than checking out without it, and reports an average 14% increase in returning-user conversion among businesses with a large repeat customer base. These are Stripe's own figures for its product, not independent results, so treat them as a direction rather than a promise.


Reaching customers across the United States and abroad


A man works at a laptop among parcels, with a world map on the wall behind him

If you sell to shoppers in the United States, offer the ways they already pay. Stripe's published US pricing lists 2.9% plus 30 cents per successful domestic card transaction. It also lists ACH Direct Debit, which takes money straight from a bank account, at 0.8% with a $5.00 cap. These are Stripe's standard published prices, so check your own account terms before you set your margins. Stripe's pricing page sets out the rates.


Buyers abroad pay differently. Stripe's pricing page lists support for 135+ currencies and an option to show prices in the customer's own currency, which it calls adaptive pricing, with a conversion fee starting at 2%. The same page adds 1.5% for international cards and 1% when currency conversion is needed, on top of the base rate. Those extra charges add up on overseas orders, so build them into your prices before you start selling abroad.


Fewer failed payments and easier refunds


A declined card is a lost sale you never see. Offering a second method gives a buyer somewhere to go instead of leaving. Stripe lists features such as real-time payment retries and auto-updated cards, which it says help recover payments.


Refunds and disputes are the other side of the sale, and they work differently. A refund is something you choose to send. A chargeback is a dispute a customer's bank opens, and the money can leave your account while it is decided. Stripe's pricing page lists a $15 fee, in US dollars, for each dispute you receive, and a $15 fee for responding manually, which you get back only if you win. PayPal handles buyer claims through its Resolution Center, so there is a process to follow either way. Keep order records and delivery proof in one place, because they settle most disputes.


Choosing and combining options without overcomplicating things


A phone lies on a wooden desk beside a mug, keys and an open notebook

More options is not always better. Each one has to be set up, reconciled, supported and refunded. For most small sellers, a simple mix works well:


  • One wallet or card option buyers already trust, such as PayPal or a card processor like Stripe.

  • One bank option that fits your buyers, such as ACH Direct Debit for US customers.

  • The full price, including delivery and fees, shown before the checkout page.


Start there. Add another method when customers ask for it, or when abandoned checkouts point to a missing option. Then test the checkout on your own phone before you call it finished.


The short version


A missing payment option costs sales, and the fixes are simple. Offer a trusted wallet, a bank option that suits your buyers, and clear costs up front. Then read your providers' own fee schedules and protection terms, and keep your records tidy for refunds and disputes.


Comments


 

© 2026 20something media (pty) ltd. All rights reserved.

​

bottom of page